Tom Hanks Vietnam War

Michael Medved article question?
Here’s the question: why does Medved disagree with Tom Hank’s line ” if we can bring private ryan back to his mother, this whole God-awful was will have meant something?” do u agree with medved?
Heres the section from tht article:
Every once in a while we’ll still get a war film of this kind. Saving Private Ryan is an example, I think—even though there is a line in it where the Tom Hanks character says, “If we can bring Private Ryan back to his mother, then this whole god-awful war will have meant something.” Needless to say, WWII would have meant something even if Private Ryan had been lost. Another example is Glory, a great Civil War movie about a famous African-American regiment, made up partly of former slaves, and its doomed but gallant assault on Fort Wagner in South Carolina. And there was Mel Gibson’s We Were Soldiers, the single finest film ever made about Vietnam. But such traditional war movies are now the rare exception.
I personally think Hanks was referring to the character’s quest to find Private Ryan, and not referring to World War II as a whole. I don’t know if Medved made that mistake, or you made one in your interpretation.
Forrest Gump rescues Bubba in Vietnam
|
|
SAVING PRIVATE RYAN Movie poster TOM HANKS, Matt Damon, Tom Sizemore Vietnam War $11.99 |
|
|
The Pacific $45.49 Tom Hanks and Steven Spielberg have long since shown that they can spin a good World War II yarn. But while their previous collaborations (Saving Private Ryan, which they starred in and directed, respectively, and Band of Brothers, for which they were part of the producing team) were set in Europe, The Pacific is their first look at the conflict with the Japanese on the other side of the world–an… |
|
|
We Were Soldiers (Widescreen Edition) $3.13 Based on the book by Lt. Col. Harold Moore (ret.) and journalist Joseph Galloway, We Were Soldiers offers a dignified reminder that the Vietnam War yielded its own crop of American heroes. Departing from Hollywood’s typically cynical treatment of the war, writer-director Randall Wallace focuses on the first engagement of American soldiers with the North Vietnamese enemy in November 1965. Moore (pl… |
|
|
TOM HANKS BIG NEW BLU RAY DISC MOVIE CLASSIC FILM ELIZABETH PERKINS $19.99 |
|
|
Apollo 13 (Widescreen 2-Disc Anniversary Edition), DVD, Tom Hanks, Bill Paxton, $22.62 |
|
|
TOY STORY 8×10 photo signed by 2 rp Tom Hanks & Tim Allen *MINT* $6.99 |
|
|
Bachelor Party WS DVD 2009 Tom Hanks Adrian Zmed $7.99 |
|
|
The Polar Express [VHS], Acceptable VHS, Tom Hanks, Chris Coppola, Michae, Rober $2.97 |
|
|
TOY STORY 8×10 photo signed by 2 rp Tom Hanks & Tim Allen *MINT* $6.99 |
|
|
Tom Hanks Autographed/Signed 8×10 Photo/Forrest Gump $85.00 |
|
|
TOY STORY- TOM HANKS & TIM ALLEN AUTOGRAPHED SIGNED 8X10 PHOTO w/ C.O.A. $175.00 |
|
|
TOM HANKS ROAD TO PERDITION Signed Autographed PSA/DNA 16×20 PHOTO @RARE@ ONLY 1 $199.99 |
|
|
*LOW OPEN* Tom Hanks, FORREST GUMP STAR , Signed 8×10 Color Photo w/COA $44.85 |